Skip to content
Colleagues shaking hands.

E&O Sr. Underwriter (Hybrid - Chicago or NYC)

Title: Sr. Underwriter- Hybrid
Location: This position is hybrid, based in Chicago or New York City.

Company Overview:

At Vault Commercial, we unlock value for our commercial customers. As a fast-growing disruptor, Vault is fueled by an experienced team of best-in-class leaders and professionals who are relentlessly focused on delivering for our customers and partnering with their brokers. We are flexible and focused —licensed to write business in all 50 states via multiple channels by: individually underwriting specialty business on our Vault E&S Insurance Company paper, supporting MGAs and programs, acting as an MGA through our own Combination Specialty Underwriters, and/or acting as a reinsurer. We've developed a state-of-the-art technology platform to quickly and accurately deliver policy documents and provide data and analytics.

We are looking for the best and the brightest talent inspired to protect what matters most to our clients, and we have a team, a culture, and a philosophy to be the best at what we do.

This role will be hybrid, either in our New York or Chicago office.

Why Choose Vault:

  • 46% of our workforce was referred by someone at Vault.
  • 37% growth rate in staff since December 2021
  • Our Financial Strength is rated an A- by AM Best.
  • Rated 4.5 stars based on our customer experience reviews
  • Our leaders are respected innovators with decades of experience in the insurance industry.
  • Vault’s proprietary technology allows for enhanced capabilities, speed, and efficiency.
  • Leading high-net-worth insurance provider with a foundation in customized solutions
  • Comprehensive benefits tailored to your lifestyle

 

Job Responsibilities:

  • Build and maintain strong broker and client relationships to drive long-term partnerships and profitable growth.

  • Deliver accurate, timely, and professional communications that reinforce Vault’s underwriting discipline and value proposition.

  • Underwrite a complex portfolio with multiple E&O products, including new and renewal business, in accordance with Vault’s underwriting strategy.

  • Perform general underwriting functions, including submission reviews, coverage analysis, pricing assessment, and establishing policy terms and conditions within authorized limits.

  • Work collaboratively with the entire team and operate independently as appropriate.

  • Mentor, coach, and provide technical guidance to junior staff, supporting skill development, knowledge transfer, and adherence to underwriting best practices.

  • Serve as a senior team contributor working collaboratively, promoting a culture of accountability, and continuously seeking areas of improvement.

  • Communicate with claims staff to review and discuss individual claim files and actively participate in regular departmental claims reviews.

  • Stay current on major industry issues and developments via trade publications, news media, industry events, industry relationships, etc.

  • Represent Vault in broker and client meetings, applying strategic judgment and market expertise to structure solutions that balance competitiveness with Vault’s underwriting strategy and profitability.

  • Maintain accountability for portfolio management, including monitoring performance, rate adequacy, loss trends, and profitability, and taking proactive action to achieve underwriting and financial targets.

  • Demonstrate a strong sense of urgency and accountability by proactively managing open items, following up consistently, keeping producers and clients informed throughout the underwriting lifecycle, and seeking timely resolution when issues arise.

  • You will collaborate as needed with other Vault departments for Commercial division priorities: IT/data, marketing, licensing, actuarial, etc.

  • Take pride and ownership in providing service within the company-established guidelines for timeliness, quality, and effectiveness.

  • Travel to interact with brokers and clients, build relationships, and grow your and Vault’s presence at industry events.

 

Preferred Qualifications:
  • Bachelor’s degree or commensurate relevant experience preferred.

  • CPCU, RPLU, and/or other relevant insurance designations are a plus.

  • Minimum 6 years of Errors & Omissions underwriting experience; other insurance underwriting experience is a plus.

  • Technical underwriting knowledge and skills reflective of progression in positions of increasing responsibility.

  • Demonstrated ability to build and maintain producer relationships.

  • Excellent interpersonal and communication skills (both written and verbal).

  • Strong attention to detail.

  • Strong organizational skills.

  • Must strive to provide service levels that exceed industry standards and demonstrate teamwork across functional areas.

  • Possess the aptitude to work in a highly competitive market, be innovative in business production and retention, and be able to adapt to changing markets and internal requirements.

  • Strong time management skills, with the ability to prioritize and handle multiple tasks.

  • Resourceful and results-driven with strong problem-solving and analytical skills.

  • The ability to work both independently and as part of a team.

  • Proficient with Microsoft Office products and internet research tools.

  • Ability to travel overnight up to 30%.

 

Benefits:

  • Flexible Spending Accounts & Health Savings Account, with company contributions
  • Company-paid comprehensive life & disability insurance plans
  • 24/7 Telehealth doctor access, virtual wellness screenings, Employee Assistance Programs
  • Company 401(k) retirement plan with Day 1 eligibility (6% company match, 100% immediate vesting)
  • 23 PTO days accrued yearly
  • 11 paid holidays
 
 
Vault is committed to providing equal opportunities to all employees and employment applicants. It prohibits discrimination and harassment of any type, regardless of race, color, religion, age, sex, national origin, disability status, genetics, protected veteran status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state, or local laws.
 
We believe diversity makes us better, and we seek to create a workplace where all feel a sense of belonging. 

In compliance with local law, we are disclosing the compensation range for roles to be performed in New York.  Actual salaries may vary based on factors including but not limited to location, experience, role, and performance. The range listed is just one component of Vault’s total compensation package for employees.

Salary Description
$115,000-$140,000

More Career Opportunities